2 1393467 IT Spotlights: The grand scheme of things <p>Schemes give brokers an edge in an otherwise standardised market, but failure is likely without the initial legwork and a willingness to ‘think outside the box’</p> 0 0 en d MMMM yyyy Issue 03-11-2011 2011-11-09T11:08:00+00:00 2011-11-09T11:08:00 Issue 03-11-2011 1 it-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things/1393467.article Schemes give brokers an edge in an otherwise standardised market, but failure is likely without the initial legwork and a willingness to ‘think outside the box’ 1 <div class="inline_image image_size_med inline_image_left" data-attachment="22718" data-sequence="2"> <p class="picture"> <img alt="pension fund scheme trustee magazine investment training" src="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xAny/7/1/8/22718_alternative_line.jpg" srcset="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xAny/7/1/8/22718_alternative_line.jpg 480w" loading="lazy" class="lazyloaded" width="580" height="385"> </p> </div><p>The market for schemes has grown rapidly over the past 10 years and is currently estimated to be worth more than £1bn in gross written premium.</p><p>A report published earlier this year by insurer MMA revealed that half of UK brokers now manage schemes, covering everything from toupée insurance to policies that insure against wine tasters losing their sense of smell.</p><p>The advantages for brokers are clear. Schemes give them an edge in an increasingly standardised insurance market, another means to exploit their usefulness to clients and provide that holy grail of “added value” against competition from online aggregators and the large direct selling insurers.</p><div class=" inline_image" style="width: 377px;"><p class="picture"><img alt="Broker Views" src="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png" sizes="(max-width: 1023px) 100vw, 780px" srcset="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 480w,https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/600xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 600w,https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/780xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 780w" loading="lazy" class="lazyloaded"></p></div><p>And, of course, schemes offer brokers a targeted bloc of clients with a single insurance requirement, which enables brokers to create and control their own unique proposition in terms of product and service.</p><blockquote><p>The biggest single issue in schemes failing is the failure of the broker to really embed it in their business.”</p><p class="quotesource">John Bibby, UK General</p></blockquote><p>From an insurers perspective, a scheme offers a profitable business that by its nature comes with limited competition and is inexpensive to run because it is administered by the broker.</p><p>“Schemes give brokers their own brand and the freedom to choose what they do about rating,” explains UK General sales director John Bibby. “They offer brokers the opportunity to be master of their own destiny. If all you sell is the standard insurance offering, it’s difficult to differentiate yourself. Schemes allow brokers to become a specialist.”</p><p>Peter Elliot, head of marketing at broker Bluefin, where schemes account for around 10% of business, adds that the speed and efficiency of executing schemes business is also a crucial factor in their appeal to brokers. “As long as a broker has done the preparatory work properly, found the right insurer, developed the right product and pitched it at the right price, schemes business is pretty straightforward.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2>Market view</h2><h4><strong>Room for growth – Jason Cobine, Cobine Carmelson</strong></h4><p>I think the schemes market will grow in the future, but brokers will need to keep up to date with their target market and gather feedback to keep ahead of both changes in the sector they’re covering and the wider insurance industry, particularly online purchasing.</p><p>Busy people want to do their business online, but the challenge is they don’t understand what they are buying, so brokers offering a niche service need to help.</p><p>But I also think that in future brokers will need to concentrate on two or more sectors with schemes, as UK plc has its winners and losers.</p></div><p>But a successful scheme requires a good deal of spade work, first in investigating a market and creating a product, and then persuading an insurer to underwrite it. And although large insurers are taking a greater interest in schemes, most have strict entry requirements, both in terms of adopting a scheme and staying with it.</p><p>“I’d say that around 70%-80% of schemes we look at fail at an early stage of review,” Bibby says. “In my experience, once a scheme is running, the biggest single issue in it failing is the failure of the broker to really embed it in their business. Sometimes people selling the scheme in a broker’s front office aren’t committed to it, perhaps because they preferred working with a different insurer or with different clients.</p><p>“You can have a clever idea and a good strategy but you must have good execution. The culture of the broker has to be right.”</p><h3><strong>Think outside the box</strong></h3><p>But Jason Cobine, who runs small London-based broker Cobine Carmelson, believes insurers are often the biggest single obstacle to getting schemes off the ground and keeping them in the air. “Most schemes fail to fly because underwriters aren’t entrepreneurial enough,” he says. “Insurers just aren’t very good at making schemes work. I have lots of discussions about schemes but insurers rarely want to do new things, they see things differently to brokers.”</p><p>Graeme Clark, a director with Gloucester-based small broker Norman P Partridge, agrees. “Underwriting agencies have much more of a ‘can do’ attitude when it comes to schemes than the bigger insurers.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2><strong>Market view</strong></h2><h4><strong>Small brokers beware – Julian Beard, John Beard &amp; Sons</strong></h4><p>Generally speaking, the schemes market, much like the open market, is quite soft at the moment and it’s difficult for new entrants to come into the market.</p><p>In terms of the future, I believe it will become more difficult to run schemes. One of the reasons for that is that as schemes increasingly go online there is a prospect that the big aggregators and insurers could take over the market, using their weight from other areas of their business that are profitable to carry poorer performing schemes.</p><p>Small brokers simply cannot do that and will find it harder to compete.</p></div><p>Not everyone puts the blame at the door of insurers. “I think it’s true to say that many insurers have heard it all before when brokers present ideas, but it goes back to preparation,” Bluefin’s Elliot insists. “If a broker has done his work properly, an insurer will put together a scheme and make it succeed.”</p><p>Allianz Commercial director of commercial broker markets Simon McGinn adds: “The key to any successful scheme is working closely with the broker to understand what is needed, that’s what makes the partnership profitable for both parties. Well-defined schemes have clear advantages.”</p><blockquote><p>The key to any successful scheme is working closely with the broker to understand what is needed.”</p><p class="quotesource">Simon McGinn, Allianz</p></blockquote><p>But a number of brokers believe that despite the recent growth in schemes, the market may have reached a plateau, with fewer new schemes being launched and a number of covers being withdrawn.</p><p>Southampton-based broker John Beard &amp; Son relies on schemes for around 60% of its business. “The schemes market is ticking along at the moment,” managing director Julian Beard says.</p><p>“But increasingly insurers want more information before getting involved. There are more requests for MI [management information] than there used to be, stemming I think from requests from government and the EU. If insurers are delegating authority, they now need to keep a close eye on who they are delegating it to.”</p><h3><strong>Decisions on delegation</strong></h3><p>Delegation is increasingly becoming an issue against a backdrop of the continuing recession and new financial regulations, with some insurers pulling back from delegating authority. More than one broker said the entry requirement for getting a delegated scheme adopted by one of the big insurance players started in the region of £500,000.</p><p>“The compliance requirements of managing a full delegated authority mean that the GWP needs to be meaningful for any insurer to be able to allocate enough resource to make the venture sustainable for either side,” MMA Insurance schemes manager Chris Withers explains. “Solvency II has implications here, as we all need to be much more transparent about the use of our capital.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2>Market view</h2><h4><strong>Local brokers will gain – Graeme Clark, Norman P Partridge</strong></h4><p>I believe the schemes market is still growing and will continue to grow in the future, particularly for provincial brokers. Schemes are pretty much tailor-made for provincial brokers, who can capitalise on their knowledge of their local market.</p><p>As insurance gets more standardised more and more clients will develop a greater appetite for an individual policy that is personal to their area and needs. Schemes allow a broker to look at risks in more detail and that means you make better decisions and provide a better and more profitable service for you and your clients - that’s why they have a future.</p></div><p>Elliot agrees that insurers want a ‘critical mass’ in terms of GWP, but adds there isn’t a single-figure starting point. Moreover, there are plenty of delegated schemes with an initial book value of £100,000.</p><p>“If you can get the endorsement of a trade association, or something similar, that can be crucial to a scheme’s success, regardless of its size,” Elliot says.</p><p>Clark adds that many schemes now have a book value of £50,000, but says brokers need to shop around. “That size of account is achievable for a lot of provincial brokers. Of course, bigger insurance companies probably won’t go for it, but it’s good business for underwriting agencies and they’re willing to take it on,” he says.</p><p>Commission on schemes obviously varies but in general it is much higher than that earned on standard insurance, primarily because of the additional work carried out by the broker.</p><p>“The average broking commission on a scheme is 20%,” Clark says. “It can be as high as 30% or as low as 10%, but I have the flexibility to adjust the commission as I see fit and frankly I’d rather write a good risk at 10% than a bad risk at 30% because maybe next year I can earn a bit more on the good risk. Don’t forget, it’s the good risks that produce a profit.”</p> Features 6 Today's Date 2011-11-09T11:08:00+00:00 1 0 2024-01-19T15:44:16.637+00:00 1 0 0 PLACEHODER FOR POST PROCESSING 10000 0 1
IT Spotlights
1087 0 0 0 0 0 1 11 1 1 1 1 4 0 0 N 1 0 www.insurancetimes.co.uk/ 0 0 NoSourceCode 0 0 |aSme|IT Metered Free|Brokers|Schemes| |12946#aSme|13140#IT Metered Free|13866#Brokers|14506#Schemes| |12946|13140|13866|14506| 0 0 0.0 0 0
<!--facebook--> <li> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3a%2f%2fwww.insurancetimes.co.uk%2fit-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things%2f1393467.article&e=IT+Spotlights%3a+The+grand+scheme+of+things" class="facebook" title="Share this on Facebook" target="_blank"></a> </li> <!-- twitter--> <li> <a href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=IT+Spotlights%3a+The+grand+scheme+of+things&url=https%3a%2f%2fwww.insurancetimes.co.uk%2fit-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things%2f1393467.article" class="twitter" title="Share this on Twitter" target="_blank"></a> </li> <!--linked in--> <li> <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/cws/share?url=https%3a%2f%2fwww.insurancetimes.co.uk%2fit-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things%2f1393467.article" class="linkedin" title="Share this on Linked in" target="_blank"></a> </li>
ARTICLES Related articles 1 MGRID 1 6 6 0 1 0 1 1 MORE More articles 1 MGRID 2 6 6 0 1 0 1 1 COMMENT Comment section 1 3 0 0 0 0 0 0
combined_carousel 400x400 480x480 600x600 800x800 emailrss_story_full_inline_full emailrss_story_inline_full 560xAny emailrss_story_full_inline_med emailrss_story_inline_med 560xAny emailrss_story_inline_small 480xAny story_twitter_card_gallery story_twitter_card_summary 1120xAny story_open_graph 1024x536 comment_avatar issue_index_thumb my_library recent_posts_small recent_stories_small section-avatar-user story_author_top_block story_byline story_columnist story_gallery_pickme 80x80 80x80 native_byline_image 50x50 50x50 story_byline_image 38x38 38x38 listblock_thumbs_medium 159x106 159x106 email_spin_thumb listblock_thumbs_small most_commented_thumbnail most_popular_thumbnail spin2_foot_onecolumn_thumb_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_mainright_onecolumn_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_thumb_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_thumb_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_thumb_twocolumn_column2_colour1 100x67 100x67 company_person_image story_restof_rhs_large 180x120 180x120 rssFeed 90xAny 90xAny current_issue 180xAny 180xAny email_spin_full 560x400 560x400 email_spin_half spin_video_thumb 270x180 270x180 listblock_thumbs_media native_feature_image story_audio_related 380x253 380x253 magazine_cover 146xany 146xany promoted_story_navigation 274x183 274x183 pub_index_small 380xAny 380xAny rss_image_preview 280x188 280x188 section-avatar-main 120x120 120x120 spin2_carousel_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_carousel_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_carousel_main_onecolumn_column1 spin2_carousel_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_carousel_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_full_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_full_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_full_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumns_column1 spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumns_column2 spin2_gridlayout_top_twocolumns_column1 spin2_gridlayout_top_twocolumns_column2 spin2_main_onecolumn_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_full_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_full_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_full_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 460x307 460x307 spin2_exhibitor_foot_threecolumns_column1 spin2_exhibitor_foot_threecolumns_column2 spin2_exhibitor_foot_threecolumns_column3 spin2_exhibitor_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column1 spin2_exhibitor_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column2 spin2_exhibitor_top_threecolumns_column1 spin2_exhibitor_top_threecolumns_column2 spin2_exhibitor_top_threecolumns_column3 spin2_exhibitor_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column1 spin2_exhibitor_top_twocolumnssmallright_column2 200x200 200x200 spin2_scroller_foot_onecolumn_column1 spin2_scroller_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_scroller_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_scroller_main_onecolumn_column1 spin2_scroller_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_scroller_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 252x172 252x172 spin2_scroller_top_onecolumn_column1 spin2_scroller_top_onecolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_scroller_top_onecolumn_column1_colour2 380x259 380x259 story_inline_med 480xAny 480xAny story_inline_small 280xAny 280xAny sponsor_byline_image 50x50fit 50x50fit directory_article_related_companies 100x67fitpad[255]-90 100x67fitpad[255]-90 directory_associate_companies 213x142fitpad[255]-90 213x142fitpad[255]-90 story_video_latest 380x253 380x253 100x67 story_related_images_small 140x93 140x93 180x120 spin2_hero_thumb 100x67 230x153 380x253 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_main_onecolumn_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column1_colour1 100x67 100x67 220x147 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumns_column2 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumns_column2 460x307 460x307 580x386 biography_avatar contacts_avatar profile_avatar_large 80x80 80x80 180x180 story_author_small 112x112 112x112 112x112 story_preview_thumb 100x67 100x67 380x253 spin2_carousel_top_onecolumn_column1 460x307 460x307 680x384 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_full_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 620x413 spin2_carousel_foot_onecolumn_column1 460x307 460x307 680x384 spin2_foot_onecolumn_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_onecolumn_half_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 620x413 sponsor_avatar 80x80fit 80x80fit 180x180fit story_native_small 112x112 112x112 112x112 story_native_medium 112x112fitpad[255] 74x74fitpad[255] 112x112fitpad[255] story_author_medium 112x112 74x74 112x112 listblock_thumbs_medium 159x106 159x106 159x106 159x106 listblock_lead 339x226 339x226 400x267 500x333 580x387 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideleft_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideleft_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideright_column3 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideright_column3 460x307 460x307 480x320 story_video_related 380x253 380x253 100x67 story_audio_index 480x270 480x270 600x338 780x439 story_inline_full 480xany 480xany 600xany 780xany text-media-spinblock 460xany 460xany 580xany 770xany spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 415x277 415x277 230x153 spin2_gridlayout_col4_ spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 415x277 415x277 230x153 my_lcp_thumb 80x80 80x80 80x80 120x120 spin2_foot_onecolumn_half_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_main_onecolumn_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_half_twocolumn_column1_colour1 173x115 173x115 275x184 460x307 spin2_mainright_onecolumn_full_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 306x204 374x249 spin2_piccarousel_mainright_onecolumn_column1 460x307 460x307 780x520 374x249 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_full_column3_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_full_column3_colour1 460x307 460x307 620x413 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_full_column1_colour1 spin2_main_onecolumn_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_full_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 780x520 spin2_foot_twocolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_full_column2_colour1 460x307 460x307 620x413 spin_video_poster_preview 414x277 414x277 580x386 748x502 940x631 1200x805 spin2_foot_twocolumns_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_half_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_half_twocolumn_column2_colour1 173x115 173x115 300x200 460x307 spin2_main_twocolumns_half_column1_colour1 173x115 174x115 300x200 460x307 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumns_column2 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumns_column3 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumns_column2 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumns_column3 460x307 460x307 768x512 374x249 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 460x307 460x307 780x520 600x400 spin2_piccarousel_main_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_piccarousel_main_twocolumnssmallright_column1 460x307 460x307 480x320 374x249 listblock_thumbs 100x67 100x67 172x115 220x148 280x188 story_full_inline_med 480xany 480xany 600xany 780xany 810xany spin2_gridlayout_main_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_gridlayout_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 415x277 415x277 230x153 250x167 story_full_inline_full 480xany 480xany 600xany 780xany 980xany 1180xany spin2_foot_onecolumn_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_full_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 780x520 1180x787 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumnswideleft_column3 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumnswideright_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideleft_column3 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideright_column1 460x307 460x307 780x520 374x249 374x249 directory_people_srp 100x67 100x67 172x115 220x148 280x188 spin2_piccarousel_main_onecolumn_column1 460x307 460x307 780x520 660x440 780x520 spin2_herocarousel 460x307 460x307 786x524 750x500 750x500 spin2_foot_threecolumns_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_half_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_half_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_half_column2_colour1 spin2_mainright_onecolumn_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_half_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_half_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_half_column2_colour1 460x307 460x307 306x204 360x240 100x67 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column1 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column2 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumnssmallright_column2 460x307 460x307 748x502 780x520 374x249 spin2_piccarousel_main_twocolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_main_twocolumns_column2 460x307 460x307 780x520 320x213 460x307 spin2_piccarousel_foot_onecolumn_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_onecolumn_column1 460x307 414x277 748x502 940x631 1200x805 company-banner 480xany 480xany 780xany 1180xany 1180xany story_gallery_onshow 480x320fitpad[0] 480x320fitpad[0] 768x512fitpad[0] 980x653fitpad[0] story_inline_gallery 480x320fitpad[0] 480x320fitpad[0] 600x400fitpad[0] 768x512fitpad[0] spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_half_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_half_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_half_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 306x204 360x240 275x183 374x249 spin2_hero_preview 480x270 480x270 780x439 1180x664 1600x900 longform 1600x900 480x270 780x439 1180x664 1600x900 longformgallerystyle1 1600x900 480x270 780x439 1180x664 1600x900 2000x1333 longformgallerystyle2 1600x900 480x854 780x1040 1280x853 1600x900 2000x1333 longformgallerystyle3 1600x900 480x270 780x439 1180x664 1600x900 2000x1333 story_full_browserwidth 480xAny 480xAny 600xAny 768xAny 1024xAny 1280xAny 2000xAny attachments_main 480x320fit 480x320fit 780x520fit 1024x682fit 1590x1060fit story_inline_gallery_full 480x320fitpad[0] 480x320fitpad[0] 600x400fitpad[0] 780x520fitpad[0] 980x653fitpad[0] 1180x786fitpad[0] directory_listblock_thumbs spin2_gridlayout_foot_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_top_onecolumn_column1 415x277 415x277 230x153 320x213 375x250 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_half_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_half_column3_colour1 460x307 460x307 306x204 360x240 174x116 226x150 directory_company_footer_logo 100x67fitpad[255]-90 100x67fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 directory_company_header_logo 100x67fitpad[255]-90 100x67fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 300x200fitpad[255]-90 directory_company_srp 100x67fitpad[255]-90 100x67fitpad[255]-90 169x113fitpad[255]-90 281x187fitpad[255]-90 281x187fitpad[255]-90 story_picturestory 480x270 480x270 600x338 768x432 1024x576 1280x720 2000x1125 story_herostory 480x480 480x480 600x600 768x768 1024x1024 1280x640 2000x1060 spinheaderlandscape 380x253 380x253 768x512 582x388 spinheadercircular 380x380 380x380 spinheaderbackground 480x270 480x270 768x432 1024x576 1280x720 2000x853 spin2_gridlayout_col4_foot_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_col4_top_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_col4_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_gridlayout_col4_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_gridlayout_col4_main_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_col4_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 181x121 181x121 460x307 258x171
2 1393467 IT Spotlights: The grand scheme of things <p>Schemes give brokers an edge in an otherwise standardised market, but failure is likely without the initial legwork and a willingness to ‘think outside the box’</p> 0 0 en d MMMM yyyy Issue 03-11-2011 2011-11-09T11:08:00+00:00 2011-11-09T11:08:00 Issue 03-11-2011 1 it-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things/1393467.article Schemes give brokers an edge in an otherwise standardised market, but failure is likely without the initial legwork and a willingness to ‘think outside the box’ 1 <div class="inline_image image_size_med inline_image_left" data-attachment="22718" data-sequence="2"> <p class="picture"> <img alt="pension fund scheme trustee magazine investment training" src="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xAny/7/1/8/22718_alternative_line.jpg" srcset="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xAny/7/1/8/22718_alternative_line.jpg 480w" loading="lazy" class="lazyloaded" width="580" height="385"> </p> </div><p>The market for schemes has grown rapidly over the past 10 years and is currently estimated to be worth more than £1bn in gross written premium.</p><p>A report published earlier this year by insurer MMA revealed that half of UK brokers now manage schemes, covering everything from toupée insurance to policies that insure against wine tasters losing their sense of smell.</p><p>The advantages for brokers are clear. Schemes give them an edge in an increasingly standardised insurance market, another means to exploit their usefulness to clients and provide that holy grail of “added value” against competition from online aggregators and the large direct selling insurers.</p><div class=" inline_image" style="width: 377px;"><p class="picture"><img alt="Broker Views" src="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png" sizes="(max-width: 1023px) 100vw, 780px" srcset="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 480w,https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/600xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 600w,https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/780xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 780w" loading="lazy" class="lazyloaded"></p></div><p>And, of course, schemes offer brokers a targeted bloc of clients with a single insurance requirement, which enables brokers to create and control their own unique proposition in terms of product and service.</p><blockquote><p>The biggest single issue in schemes failing is the failure of the broker to really embed it in their business.”</p><p class="quotesource">John Bibby, UK General</p></blockquote><p>From an insurers perspective, a scheme offers a profitable business that by its nature comes with limited competition and is inexpensive to run because it is administered by the broker.</p><p>“Schemes give brokers their own brand and the freedom to choose what they do about rating,” explains UK General sales director John Bibby. “They offer brokers the opportunity to be master of their own destiny. If all you sell is the standard insurance offering, it’s difficult to differentiate yourself. Schemes allow brokers to become a specialist.”</p><p>Peter Elliot, head of marketing at broker Bluefin, where schemes account for around 10% of business, adds that the speed and efficiency of executing schemes business is also a crucial factor in their appeal to brokers. “As long as a broker has done the preparatory work properly, found the right insurer, developed the right product and pitched it at the right price, schemes business is pretty straightforward.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2>Market view</h2><h4><strong>Room for growth – Jason Cobine, Cobine Carmelson</strong></h4><p>I think the schemes market will grow in the future, but brokers will need to keep up to date with their target market and gather feedback to keep ahead of both changes in the sector they’re covering and the wider insurance industry, particularly online purchasing.</p><p>Busy people want to do their business online, but the challenge is they don’t understand what they are buying, so brokers offering a niche service need to help.</p><p>But I also think that in future brokers will need to concentrate on two or more sectors with schemes, as UK plc has its winners and losers.</p></div><p>But a successful scheme requires a good deal of spade work, first in investigating a market and creating a product, and then persuading an insurer to underwrite it. And although large insurers are taking a greater interest in schemes, most have strict entry requirements, both in terms of adopting a scheme and staying with it.</p><p>“I’d say that around 70%-80% of schemes we look at fail at an early stage of review,” Bibby says. “In my experience, once a scheme is running, the biggest single issue in it failing is the failure of the broker to really embed it in their business. Sometimes people selling the scheme in a broker’s front office aren’t committed to it, perhaps because they preferred working with a different insurer or with different clients.</p><p>“You can have a clever idea and a good strategy but you must have good execution. The culture of the broker has to be right.”</p><h3><strong>Think outside the box</strong></h3><p>But Jason Cobine, who runs small London-based broker Cobine Carmelson, believes insurers are often the biggest single obstacle to getting schemes off the ground and keeping them in the air. “Most schemes fail to fly because underwriters aren’t entrepreneurial enough,” he says. “Insurers just aren’t very good at making schemes work. I have lots of discussions about schemes but insurers rarely want to do new things, they see things differently to brokers.”</p><p>Graeme Clark, a director with Gloucester-based small broker Norman P Partridge, agrees. “Underwriting agencies have much more of a ‘can do’ attitude when it comes to schemes than the bigger insurers.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2><strong>Market view</strong></h2><h4><strong>Small brokers beware – Julian Beard, John Beard &amp; Sons</strong></h4><p>Generally speaking, the schemes market, much like the open market, is quite soft at the moment and it’s difficult for new entrants to come into the market.</p><p>In terms of the future, I believe it will become more difficult to run schemes. One of the reasons for that is that as schemes increasingly go online there is a prospect that the big aggregators and insurers could take over the market, using their weight from other areas of their business that are profitable to carry poorer performing schemes.</p><p>Small brokers simply cannot do that and will find it harder to compete.</p></div><p>Not everyone puts the blame at the door of insurers. “I think it’s true to say that many insurers have heard it all before when brokers present ideas, but it goes back to preparation,” Bluefin’s Elliot insists. “If a broker has done his work properly, an insurer will put together a scheme and make it succeed.”</p><p>Allianz Commercial director of commercial broker markets Simon McGinn adds: “The key to any successful scheme is working closely with the broker to understand what is needed, that’s what makes the partnership profitable for both parties. Well-defined schemes have clear advantages.”</p><blockquote><p>The key to any successful scheme is working closely with the broker to understand what is needed.”</p><p class="quotesource">Simon McGinn, Allianz</p></blockquote><p>But a number of brokers believe that despite the recent growth in schemes, the market may have reached a plateau, with fewer new schemes being launched and a number of covers being withdrawn.</p><p>Southampton-based broker John Beard &amp; Son relies on schemes for around 60% of its business. “The schemes market is ticking along at the moment,” managing director Julian Beard says.</p><p>“But increasingly insurers want more information before getting involved. There are more requests for MI [management information] than there used to be, stemming I think from requests from government and the EU. If insurers are delegating authority, they now need to keep a close eye on who they are delegating it to.”</p><h3><strong>Decisions on delegation</strong></h3><p>Delegation is increasingly becoming an issue against a backdrop of the continuing recession and new financial regulations, with some insurers pulling back from delegating authority. More than one broker said the entry requirement for getting a delegated scheme adopted by one of the big insurance players started in the region of £500,000.</p><p>“The compliance requirements of managing a full delegated authority mean that the GWP needs to be meaningful for any insurer to be able to allocate enough resource to make the venture sustainable for either side,” MMA Insurance schemes manager Chris Withers explains. “Solvency II has implications here, as we all need to be much more transparent about the use of our capital.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2>Market view</h2><h4><strong>Local brokers will gain – Graeme Clark, Norman P Partridge</strong></h4><p>I believe the schemes market is still growing and will continue to grow in the future, particularly for provincial brokers. Schemes are pretty much tailor-made for provincial brokers, who can capitalise on their knowledge of their local market.</p><p>As insurance gets more standardised more and more clients will develop a greater appetite for an individual policy that is personal to their area and needs. Schemes allow a broker to look at risks in more detail and that means you make better decisions and provide a better and more profitable service for you and your clients - that’s why they have a future.</p></div><p>Elliot agrees that insurers want a ‘critical mass’ in terms of GWP, but adds there isn’t a single-figure starting point. Moreover, there are plenty of delegated schemes with an initial book value of £100,000.</p><p>“If you can get the endorsement of a trade association, or something similar, that can be crucial to a scheme’s success, regardless of its size,” Elliot says.</p><p>Clark adds that many schemes now have a book value of £50,000, but says brokers need to shop around. “That size of account is achievable for a lot of provincial brokers. Of course, bigger insurance companies probably won’t go for it, but it’s good business for underwriting agencies and they’re willing to take it on,” he says.</p><p>Commission on schemes obviously varies but in general it is much higher than that earned on standard insurance, primarily because of the additional work carried out by the broker.</p><p>“The average broking commission on a scheme is 20%,” Clark says. “It can be as high as 30% or as low as 10%, but I have the flexibility to adjust the commission as I see fit and frankly I’d rather write a good risk at 10% than a bad risk at 30% because maybe next year I can earn a bit more on the good risk. Don’t forget, it’s the good risks that produce a profit.”</p> Features 6 Today's Date 2011-11-09T11:08:00+00:00 1 0 2024-01-19T15:44:16.637+00:00 1 0 0 PLACEHODER FOR POST PROCESSING 10000 0 1
IT Spotlights
1087 0 0 0 0 0 1 11 1 1 1 1 4 0 0 N 1 0 www.insurancetimes.co.uk/ 0 0 NoSourceCode 0 0 |aSme|IT Metered Free|Brokers|Schemes| |12946#aSme|13140#IT Metered Free|13866#Brokers|14506#Schemes| |12946|13140|13866|14506| 0 0 0.0 0 0
INTRO Intro/teaser 6 SYNOPSIS Access denied intro 6
Insurance Times Fantasy Football
combined_carousel 400x400 480x480 600x600 800x800 emailrss_story_full_inline_full emailrss_story_inline_full 560xAny emailrss_story_full_inline_med emailrss_story_inline_med 560xAny emailrss_story_inline_small 480xAny story_twitter_card_gallery story_twitter_card_summary 1120xAny story_open_graph 1024x536 comment_avatar issue_index_thumb my_library recent_posts_small recent_stories_small section-avatar-user story_author_top_block story_byline story_columnist story_gallery_pickme 80x80 80x80 native_byline_image 50x50 50x50 story_byline_image 38x38 38x38 listblock_thumbs_medium 159x106 159x106 email_spin_thumb listblock_thumbs_small most_commented_thumbnail most_popular_thumbnail spin2_foot_onecolumn_thumb_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_mainright_onecolumn_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_thumb_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_thumb_column3_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_thumb_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_thumb_twocolumn_column2_colour1 100x67 100x67 company_person_image story_restof_rhs_large 180x120 180x120 rssFeed 90xAny 90xAny current_issue 180xAny 180xAny email_spin_full 560x400 560x400 email_spin_half spin_video_thumb 270x180 270x180 listblock_thumbs_media native_feature_image story_audio_related 380x253 380x253 magazine_cover 146xany 146xany promoted_story_navigation 274x183 274x183 pub_index_small 380xAny 380xAny rss_image_preview 280x188 280x188 section-avatar-main 120x120 120x120 spin2_carousel_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_carousel_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_carousel_main_onecolumn_column1 spin2_carousel_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_carousel_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_full_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_full_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_full_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumns_column1 spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumns_column2 spin2_gridlayout_top_twocolumns_column1 spin2_gridlayout_top_twocolumns_column2 spin2_main_onecolumn_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_full_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_full_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_full_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_full_twocolumn_column2_colour1 460x307 460x307 spin2_exhibitor_foot_threecolumns_column1 spin2_exhibitor_foot_threecolumns_column2 spin2_exhibitor_foot_threecolumns_column3 spin2_exhibitor_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column1 spin2_exhibitor_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column2 spin2_exhibitor_top_threecolumns_column1 spin2_exhibitor_top_threecolumns_column2 spin2_exhibitor_top_threecolumns_column3 spin2_exhibitor_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column1 spin2_exhibitor_top_twocolumnssmallright_column2 200x200 200x200 spin2_scroller_foot_onecolumn_column1 spin2_scroller_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_scroller_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_scroller_main_onecolumn_column1 spin2_scroller_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_scroller_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 252x172 252x172 spin2_scroller_top_onecolumn_column1 spin2_scroller_top_onecolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_scroller_top_onecolumn_column1_colour2 380x259 380x259 story_inline_med 480xAny 480xAny story_inline_small 280xAny 280xAny sponsor_byline_image 50x50fit 50x50fit directory_article_related_companies 100x67fitpad[255]-90 100x67fitpad[255]-90 directory_associate_companies 213x142fitpad[255]-90 213x142fitpad[255]-90 story_video_latest 380x253 380x253 100x67 story_related_images_small 140x93 140x93 180x120 spin2_hero_thumb 100x67 230x153 380x253 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_main_onecolumn_thumb_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_thumb_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_thumb_column1_colour1 100x67 100x67 220x147 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumns_column2 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumns_column2 460x307 460x307 580x386 biography_avatar contacts_avatar profile_avatar_large 80x80 80x80 180x180 story_author_small 112x112 112x112 112x112 story_preview_thumb 100x67 100x67 380x253 spin2_carousel_top_onecolumn_column1 460x307 460x307 680x384 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_full_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 620x413 spin2_carousel_foot_onecolumn_column1 460x307 460x307 680x384 spin2_foot_onecolumn_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_onecolumn_half_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 620x413 sponsor_avatar 80x80fit 80x80fit 180x180fit story_native_small 112x112 112x112 112x112 story_native_medium 112x112fitpad[255] 74x74fitpad[255] 112x112fitpad[255] story_author_medium 112x112 74x74 112x112 listblock_thumbs_medium 159x106 159x106 159x106 159x106 listblock_lead 339x226 339x226 400x267 500x333 580x387 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideleft_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideleft_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideright_column3 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideright_column3 460x307 460x307 480x320 story_video_related 380x253 380x253 100x67 story_audio_index 480x270 480x270 600x338 780x439 story_inline_full 480xany 480xany 600xany 780xany text-media-spinblock 460xany 460xany 580xany 770xany spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 415x277 415x277 230x153 spin2_gridlayout_col4_ spin2_gridlayout_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 415x277 415x277 230x153 my_lcp_thumb 80x80 80x80 80x80 120x120 spin2_foot_onecolumn_half_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_main_onecolumn_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_half_twocolumn_column1_colour1 173x115 173x115 275x184 460x307 spin2_mainright_onecolumn_full_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 306x204 374x249 spin2_piccarousel_mainright_onecolumn_column1 460x307 460x307 780x520 374x249 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_full_column3_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_full_column3_colour1 460x307 460x307 620x413 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_full_column1_colour1 spin2_main_onecolumn_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_full_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 780x520 spin2_foot_twocolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_full_column2_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_full_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_full_column2_colour1 460x307 460x307 620x413 spin_video_poster_preview 414x277 414x277 580x386 748x502 940x631 1200x805 spin2_foot_twocolumns_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_half_twocolumn_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumns_half_twocolumn_column2_colour1 173x115 173x115 300x200 460x307 spin2_main_twocolumns_half_column1_colour1 173x115 174x115 300x200 460x307 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumns_column2 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumns_column3 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumns_column2 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumns_column3 460x307 460x307 768x512 374x249 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 460x307 460x307 780x520 600x400 spin2_piccarousel_main_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_piccarousel_main_twocolumnssmallright_column1 460x307 460x307 480x320 374x249 listblock_thumbs 100x67 100x67 172x115 220x148 280x188 story_full_inline_med 480xany 480xany 600xany 780xany 810xany spin2_gridlayout_main_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_gridlayout_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 415x277 415x277 230x153 250x167 story_full_inline_full 480xany 480xany 600xany 780xany 980xany 1180xany spin2_foot_onecolumn_full_column1_colour1 spin2_top_onecolumn_full_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 780x520 1180x787 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumnswideleft_column3 spin2_piccarousel_foot_threecolumnswideright_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideleft_column3 spin2_piccarousel_top_threecolumnswideright_column1 460x307 460x307 780x520 374x249 374x249 directory_people_srp 100x67 100x67 172x115 220x148 280x188 spin2_piccarousel_main_onecolumn_column1 460x307 460x307 780x520 660x440 780x520 spin2_herocarousel 460x307 460x307 786x524 750x500 750x500 spin2_foot_threecolumns_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumns_half_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_half_column3_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_half_column2_colour1 spin2_mainright_onecolumn_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumns_half_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_half_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_half_column2_colour1 460x307 460x307 306x204 360x240 100x67 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_column1 spin2_piccarousel_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column2 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_twocolumnssmallright_column2 460x307 460x307 748x502 780x520 374x249 spin2_piccarousel_main_twocolumns_column1 spin2_piccarousel_main_twocolumns_column2 460x307 460x307 780x520 320x213 460x307 spin2_piccarousel_foot_onecolumn_column1 spin2_piccarousel_top_onecolumn_column1 460x307 414x277 748x502 940x631 1200x805 company-banner 480xany 480xany 780xany 1180xany 1180xany story_gallery_onshow 480x320fitpad[0] 480x320fitpad[0] 768x512fitpad[0] 980x653fitpad[0] story_inline_gallery 480x320fitpad[0] 480x320fitpad[0] 600x400fitpad[0] 768x512fitpad[0] spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_twocolumnssmallright_half_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_half_column1_colour1 spin2_main_twocolumnssmallright_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallleft_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_twocolumnssmallright_half_column1_colour1 460x307 460x307 306x204 360x240 275x183 374x249 spin2_hero_preview 480x270 480x270 780x439 1180x664 1600x900 longform 1600x900 480x270 780x439 1180x664 1600x900 longformgallerystyle1 1600x900 480x270 780x439 1180x664 1600x900 2000x1333 longformgallerystyle2 1600x900 480x854 780x1040 1280x853 1600x900 2000x1333 longformgallerystyle3 1600x900 480x270 780x439 1180x664 1600x900 2000x1333 story_full_browserwidth 480xAny 480xAny 600xAny 768xAny 1024xAny 1280xAny 2000xAny attachments_main 480x320fit 480x320fit 780x520fit 1024x682fit 1590x1060fit story_inline_gallery_full 480x320fitpad[0] 480x320fitpad[0] 600x400fitpad[0] 780x520fitpad[0] 980x653fitpad[0] 1180x786fitpad[0] directory_listblock_thumbs spin2_gridlayout_foot_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_top_onecolumn_column1 415x277 415x277 230x153 320x213 375x250 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_half_column2_colour1 spin2_foot_threecolumnswideright_half_column3_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideleft_half_column1_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_half_column2_colour1 spin2_top_threecolumnswideright_half_column3_colour1 460x307 460x307 306x204 360x240 174x116 226x150 directory_company_footer_logo 100x67fitpad[255]-90 100x67fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 directory_company_header_logo 100x67fitpad[255]-90 100x67fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 200x133fitpad[255]-90 300x200fitpad[255]-90 directory_company_srp 100x67fitpad[255]-90 100x67fitpad[255]-90 169x113fitpad[255]-90 281x187fitpad[255]-90 281x187fitpad[255]-90 story_picturestory 480x270 480x270 600x338 768x432 1024x576 1280x720 2000x1125 story_herostory 480x480 480x480 600x600 768x768 1024x1024 1280x640 2000x1060 spinheaderlandscape 380x253 380x253 768x512 582x388 spinheadercircular 380x380 380x380 spinheaderbackground 480x270 480x270 768x432 1024x576 1280x720 2000x853 spin2_gridlayout_col4_foot_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_col4_top_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_col4_top_twocolumnssmallleft_column2 spin2_gridlayout_col4_top_twocolumnssmallright_column1 spin2_gridlayout_col4_main_onecolumn_column1 spin2_gridlayout_col4_foot_twocolumnssmallright_column1 181x121 181x121 460x307 258x171
Brokers 13866 CATEGORY JSONNAME brokers Schemes 14506 CATEGORY JSONNAME schemes
CATEGORY 13575 Edition edition CATEGORY 13860 News news CATEGORY 13861 Analysis analysis CATEGORY 13863 Interviews analysis/interviews CATEGORY 13864 Insurers insurers CATEGORY 13866 Brokers brokers CATEGORY 13868 Commercial Lines news/commercial-lines CATEGORY 13869 Personal Lines news/personal-lines CATEGORY 13873 Admiral insurers/featured/admiral CATEGORY 13874 Ageas insurers/featured/ageas CATEGORY 13875 AIG insurers/featured/aig CATEGORY 13876 Allianz insurers/featured/allianz CATEGORY 13877 Aspen insurers/featured/aspen CATEGORY 13878 Aviva insurers/featured/aviva CATEGORY 13879 AXA insurers/featured/axa CATEGORY 13880 Brit insurers/featured/brit CATEGORY 13881 Canopius insurers/featured/canopius CATEGORY 13882 Chubb insurers/featured/chubb CATEGORY 13883 Covea insurers/featured/covea CATEGORY 13884 Direct Line Group insurers/featured/direct-line-group CATEGORY 13885 Ecclesiastical insurers/featured/ecclesiastical CATEGORY 13886 ERS insurers/featured/ers CATEGORY 13887 Esure insurers/featured/esure CATEGORY 13888 FM Global insurers/featured/fm-global CATEGORY 13890 Hiscox insurers/featured/hiscox CATEGORY 13891 Lemonade insurers/featured/lemonade CATEGORY 13892 Lloyd's of London insurers/featured/lloyds-of-london CATEGORY 13893 Markel insurers/featured/markel CATEGORY 13894 Mitsui insurers/featured/mitsui CATEGORY 13895 NIG insurers/featured/nig CATEGORY 13896 QBE insurers/featured/qbe CATEGORY 13897 RSA insurers/featured/rsa CATEGORY 13898 Sabre insurers/featured/sabre CATEGORY 13899 Saga insurers/featured/saga CATEGORY 13900 Tokio Marine Kiln insurers/featured/tokio-marine-kiln CATEGORY 13901 Travelers insurers/featured/travelers CATEGORY 13902 Zurich insurers/featured/zurich CATEGORY 13937 A-Plan brokers/featured/a-plan CATEGORY 13938 AA brokers/featured/aa CATEGORY 13939 Adrian Flux brokers/featured/adrian-flux CATEGORY 13940 Animal Friends brokers/featured/animal-friends CATEGORY 13941 Aon brokers/featured/aon CATEGORY 13942 Ardonagh brokers/featured/ardonagh CATEGORY 13943 Aston Lark brokers/featured/aston-lark CATEGORY 13944 Be Wiser brokers/featured/be-wiser CATEGORY 13945 BGL brokers/featured/bgl CATEGORY 13946 BMS brokers/featured/bms CATEGORY 13947 Bollington Wilson brokers/featured/bollington-wilson CATEGORY 13948 Bravo Group brokers/featured/bravo-group CATEGORY 13949 Brightside brokers/featured/brightside CATEGORY 13950 Clear Group brokers/featured/clear-group CATEGORY 13951 Ed Broking brokers/featured/ed-broking CATEGORY 13952 Eldon brokers/featured/eldon CATEGORY 13953 First Central brokers/featured/first-central CATEGORY 13954 Gallagher brokers/featured/gallagher CATEGORY 13955 Granite brokers/featured/granite CATEGORY 13956 GRP brokers/featured/grp CATEGORY 13957 Hastings brokers/featured/hastings CATEGORY 13958 Howden brokers/featured/howden CATEGORY 13959 Integro brokers/featured/integro CATEGORY 13960 Lockton brokers/featured/lockton CATEGORY 13961 Markerstudy brokers/featured/markerstudy CATEGORY 13962 Marsh brokers/featured/marsh CATEGORY 13963 Miller brokers/featured/miller CATEGORY 13965 PIB brokers/featured/pib CATEGORY 13966 Simply Business brokers/featured/simply-business CATEGORY 13967 THB brokers/featured/thb CATEGORY 13968 UIB brokers/featured/uib CATEGORY 13969 Willis brokers/featured/willis CATEGORY 13972 Broker Network brokers/featured/networks/broker-network CATEGORY 13973 Brokerbility brokers/featured/networks/brokerbility CATEGORY 13974 Cobra brokers/featured/networks/cobra CATEGORY 13975 Compass brokers/featured/networks/compass CATEGORY 13976 Marsh Networks brokers/featured/networks/marsh-networks CATEGORY 13977 Willis Networks brokers/featured/networks/willis-networks CATEGORY 14030 Biba 2024 biba-2024 CATEGORY 14043 Business Interruption topics/business-interruption CATEGORY 14046 Cyber topics/cyber CATEGORY 14051 Marine topics/marine CATEGORY 14053 Professional Indemnity topics/professional-indemnity CATEGORY 14054 Property topics/property CATEGORY 14058 Cyber topics/cyber CATEGORY 14059 High Net Worth topics/high-net-worth CATEGORY 14060 Household topics/household CATEGORY 14063 Motor topics/motor CATEGORY 14067 Travel topics/travel CATEGORY 14073 Artificial Intelligence topics/artificial-intelligence CATEGORY 14074 Internet of Things topics/internet-of-things CATEGORY 14075 Telematics topics/telematics CATEGORY 14076 Software Platforms topics/software-platforms CATEGORY 14077 Broker Software Platforms topics/broker-software-platforms CATEGORY 14078 eTrading topics/etrading CATEGORY 14079 Claims Technology topics/claims-technology CATEGORY 14080 Regulation topics/regulation CATEGORY 14081 Solvency topics/solvency CATEGORY 14082 Insurance Ombudsman topics/insurance-ombudsman CATEGORY 14083 M&A topics/manda CATEGORY 14084 Results topics/results CATEGORY 14085 Financial Ratings topics/financial-ratings CATEGORY 14086 Risk Management topics/risk-management CATEGORY 14087 Fraud Charter fraud-charter CATEGORY 14088 Brexit topics/brexit CATEGORY 14089 Covid-19 topics/covid-19 CATEGORY 14090 Claims topics/claims CATEGORY 14091 Unrated Insurers topics/unrated-insurers CATEGORY 14092 People Moves topics/people-moves CATEGORY 14096 Financial topics/financial CATEGORY 14105 Insurtech topics/insurtech CATEGORY 14108 LV insurers/featured/lv CATEGORY 14110 ESG topics/esg CATEGORY 14112 London Market topics/london-market CATEGORY 14184 Russia-Ukraine Conflict topics/russia-ukraine-conflict CATEGORY 14208 TechTalk analysis/techtalk CATEGORY 14218 Diversity and Inclusion topics/diversity-and-inclusion CATEGORY 14241 IT Awards 2022 it-awards-2022 CATEGORY 14276 SME Brokers brokers/sme-brokers CATEGORY 14381 Aegis insurers/featured/aegis CATEGORY 14382 Arch insurers/featured/arch CATEGORY 14383 Beazley insurers/featured/beazley CATEGORY 14384 Chaucer insurers/featured/chaucer CATEGORY 14385 Domestic and General insurers/featured/domestic-and-general CATEGORY 14386 Liberty insurers/featured/liberty CATEGORY 14387 Munich Re insurers/featured/munich-re CATEGORY 14388 NFU Mutual insurers/featured/nfu-mutual CATEGORY 14389 Sompo International insurers/featured/sompo-international CATEGORY 14506 Schemes topics/schemes CATEGORY 14549 Market topics/market SECTION 1001 News news SECTION 1032 Analysis analysis SECTION 1072 News Analysis news/news-analysis SECTION 1086 Interviews analysis/interviews SECTION 1141 Expert Views expert-views SECTION 1142 Research research SECTION 1143 IT Awards 2022 it-awards-2022 SECTION 1149 IT Awards it-awards
2 1393467 IT Spotlights: The grand scheme of things <p>Schemes give brokers an edge in an otherwise standardised market, but failure is likely without the initial legwork and a willingness to ‘think outside the box’</p> 0 0 en d MMMM yyyy Issue 03-11-2011 2011-11-09T11:08:00+00:00 2011-11-09T11:08:00 Issue 03-11-2011 1 it-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things/1393467.article Schemes give brokers an edge in an otherwise standardised market, but failure is likely without the initial legwork and a willingness to ‘think outside the box’ 1 <div class="inline_image image_size_med inline_image_left" data-attachment="22718" data-sequence="2"> <p class="picture"> <img alt="pension fund scheme trustee magazine investment training" src="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xAny/7/1/8/22718_alternative_line.jpg" srcset="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xAny/7/1/8/22718_alternative_line.jpg 480w" loading="lazy" class="lazyloaded" width="580" height="385"> </p> </div><p>The market for schemes has grown rapidly over the past 10 years and is currently estimated to be worth more than £1bn in gross written premium.</p><p>A report published earlier this year by insurer MMA revealed that half of UK brokers now manage schemes, covering everything from toupée insurance to policies that insure against wine tasters losing their sense of smell.</p><p>The advantages for brokers are clear. Schemes give them an edge in an increasingly standardised insurance market, another means to exploit their usefulness to clients and provide that holy grail of “added value” against competition from online aggregators and the large direct selling insurers.</p><div class=" inline_image" style="width: 377px;"><p class="picture"><img alt="Broker Views" src="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png" sizes="(max-width: 1023px) 100vw, 780px" srcset="https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/480xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 480w,https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/600xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 600w,https://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/780xany//Phttps://d17mj6xr9uykrr.cloudfront.net/Pictures/web/a/p/o/Screen-shot-2011-11-09-at-10.47.3_377.png 780w" loading="lazy" class="lazyloaded"></p></div><p>And, of course, schemes offer brokers a targeted bloc of clients with a single insurance requirement, which enables brokers to create and control their own unique proposition in terms of product and service.</p><blockquote><p>The biggest single issue in schemes failing is the failure of the broker to really embed it in their business.”</p><p class="quotesource">John Bibby, UK General</p></blockquote><p>From an insurers perspective, a scheme offers a profitable business that by its nature comes with limited competition and is inexpensive to run because it is administered by the broker.</p><p>“Schemes give brokers their own brand and the freedom to choose what they do about rating,” explains UK General sales director John Bibby. “They offer brokers the opportunity to be master of their own destiny. If all you sell is the standard insurance offering, it’s difficult to differentiate yourself. Schemes allow brokers to become a specialist.”</p><p>Peter Elliot, head of marketing at broker Bluefin, where schemes account for around 10% of business, adds that the speed and efficiency of executing schemes business is also a crucial factor in their appeal to brokers. “As long as a broker has done the preparatory work properly, found the right insurer, developed the right product and pitched it at the right price, schemes business is pretty straightforward.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2>Market view</h2><h4><strong>Room for growth – Jason Cobine, Cobine Carmelson</strong></h4><p>I think the schemes market will grow in the future, but brokers will need to keep up to date with their target market and gather feedback to keep ahead of both changes in the sector they’re covering and the wider insurance industry, particularly online purchasing.</p><p>Busy people want to do their business online, but the challenge is they don’t understand what they are buying, so brokers offering a niche service need to help.</p><p>But I also think that in future brokers will need to concentrate on two or more sectors with schemes, as UK plc has its winners and losers.</p></div><p>But a successful scheme requires a good deal of spade work, first in investigating a market and creating a product, and then persuading an insurer to underwrite it. And although large insurers are taking a greater interest in schemes, most have strict entry requirements, both in terms of adopting a scheme and staying with it.</p><p>“I’d say that around 70%-80% of schemes we look at fail at an early stage of review,” Bibby says. “In my experience, once a scheme is running, the biggest single issue in it failing is the failure of the broker to really embed it in their business. Sometimes people selling the scheme in a broker’s front office aren’t committed to it, perhaps because they preferred working with a different insurer or with different clients.</p><p>“You can have a clever idea and a good strategy but you must have good execution. The culture of the broker has to be right.”</p><h3><strong>Think outside the box</strong></h3><p>But Jason Cobine, who runs small London-based broker Cobine Carmelson, believes insurers are often the biggest single obstacle to getting schemes off the ground and keeping them in the air. “Most schemes fail to fly because underwriters aren’t entrepreneurial enough,” he says. “Insurers just aren’t very good at making schemes work. I have lots of discussions about schemes but insurers rarely want to do new things, they see things differently to brokers.”</p><p>Graeme Clark, a director with Gloucester-based small broker Norman P Partridge, agrees. “Underwriting agencies have much more of a ‘can do’ attitude when it comes to schemes than the bigger insurers.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2><strong>Market view</strong></h2><h4><strong>Small brokers beware – Julian Beard, John Beard &amp; Sons</strong></h4><p>Generally speaking, the schemes market, much like the open market, is quite soft at the moment and it’s difficult for new entrants to come into the market.</p><p>In terms of the future, I believe it will become more difficult to run schemes. One of the reasons for that is that as schemes increasingly go online there is a prospect that the big aggregators and insurers could take over the market, using their weight from other areas of their business that are profitable to carry poorer performing schemes.</p><p>Small brokers simply cannot do that and will find it harder to compete.</p></div><p>Not everyone puts the blame at the door of insurers. “I think it’s true to say that many insurers have heard it all before when brokers present ideas, but it goes back to preparation,” Bluefin’s Elliot insists. “If a broker has done his work properly, an insurer will put together a scheme and make it succeed.”</p><p>Allianz Commercial director of commercial broker markets Simon McGinn adds: “The key to any successful scheme is working closely with the broker to understand what is needed, that’s what makes the partnership profitable for both parties. Well-defined schemes have clear advantages.”</p><blockquote><p>The key to any successful scheme is working closely with the broker to understand what is needed.”</p><p class="quotesource">Simon McGinn, Allianz</p></blockquote><p>But a number of brokers believe that despite the recent growth in schemes, the market may have reached a plateau, with fewer new schemes being launched and a number of covers being withdrawn.</p><p>Southampton-based broker John Beard &amp; Son relies on schemes for around 60% of its business. “The schemes market is ticking along at the moment,” managing director Julian Beard says.</p><p>“But increasingly insurers want more information before getting involved. There are more requests for MI [management information] than there used to be, stemming I think from requests from government and the EU. If insurers are delegating authority, they now need to keep a close eye on who they are delegating it to.”</p><h3><strong>Decisions on delegation</strong></h3><p>Delegation is increasingly becoming an issue against a backdrop of the continuing recession and new financial regulations, with some insurers pulling back from delegating authority. More than one broker said the entry requirement for getting a delegated scheme adopted by one of the big insurance players started in the region of £500,000.</p><p>“The compliance requirements of managing a full delegated authority mean that the GWP needs to be meaningful for any insurer to be able to allocate enough resource to make the venture sustainable for either side,” MMA Insurance schemes manager Chris Withers explains. “Solvency II has implications here, as we all need to be much more transparent about the use of our capital.”</p><div class="factfile"><h2>Market view</h2><h4><strong>Local brokers will gain – Graeme Clark, Norman P Partridge</strong></h4><p>I believe the schemes market is still growing and will continue to grow in the future, particularly for provincial brokers. Schemes are pretty much tailor-made for provincial brokers, who can capitalise on their knowledge of their local market.</p><p>As insurance gets more standardised more and more clients will develop a greater appetite for an individual policy that is personal to their area and needs. Schemes allow a broker to look at risks in more detail and that means you make better decisions and provide a better and more profitable service for you and your clients - that’s why they have a future.</p></div><p>Elliot agrees that insurers want a ‘critical mass’ in terms of GWP, but adds there isn’t a single-figure starting point. Moreover, there are plenty of delegated schemes with an initial book value of £100,000.</p><p>“If you can get the endorsement of a trade association, or something similar, that can be crucial to a scheme’s success, regardless of its size,” Elliot says.</p><p>Clark adds that many schemes now have a book value of £50,000, but says brokers need to shop around. “That size of account is achievable for a lot of provincial brokers. Of course, bigger insurance companies probably won’t go for it, but it’s good business for underwriting agencies and they’re willing to take it on,” he says.</p><p>Commission on schemes obviously varies but in general it is much higher than that earned on standard insurance, primarily because of the additional work carried out by the broker.</p><p>“The average broking commission on a scheme is 20%,” Clark says. “It can be as high as 30% or as low as 10%, but I have the flexibility to adjust the commission as I see fit and frankly I’d rather write a good risk at 10% than a bad risk at 30% because maybe next year I can earn a bit more on the good risk. Don’t forget, it’s the good risks that produce a profit.”</p> Features 6 Today's Date 2011-11-09T11:08:00+00:00 1 0 2024-01-19T15:44:16.637+00:00 1 0 0 PLACEHODER FOR POST PROCESSING 10000 0 1
IT Spotlights
1087 0 0 0 0 0 1 11 1 1 1 1 4 0 0 N 1 0 www.insurancetimes.co.uk/ 0 0 NoSourceCode 0 0 |aSme|IT Metered Free|Brokers|Schemes| |12946#aSme|13140#IT Metered Free|13866#Brokers|14506#Schemes| |12946|13140|13866|14506| 0 0 0.0 0 0
<!--facebook--> <li> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3a%2f%2fwww.insurancetimes.co.uk%2fit-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things%2f1393467.article&e=IT+Spotlights%3a+The+grand+scheme+of+things" class="facebook" title="Share this on Facebook" target="_blank"></a> </li> <!-- twitter--> <li> <a href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=IT+Spotlights%3a+The+grand+scheme+of+things&url=https%3a%2f%2fwww.insurancetimes.co.uk%2fit-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things%2f1393467.article" class="twitter" title="Share this on Twitter" target="_blank"></a> </li> <!--linked in--> <li> <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/cws/share?url=https%3a%2f%2fwww.insurancetimes.co.uk%2fit-spotlights-the-grand-scheme-of-things%2f1393467.article" class="linkedin" title="Share this on Linked in" target="_blank"></a> </li>
ARTICLES Related articles 1 MGRID 1 6 6 0 1 0 1 1 MORE More articles 1 MGRID 2 6 6 0 1 0 1 1 COMMENT Comment section 1 3 0 0 0 0 0 0