A landmark ruling in the US this week, in which a man became the first person ever to receive a compensation payout from a tobacco company, is unlikely to have a knock-on effect for the UK insurance industry, say analysts.

Grady Carter, a 70-year-old ex-smoker who has had a cancerous lung removed, received $1.1m (£0.76m) from Brown & Williamson Tobacco, as a full payment plus interest on a 1995 jury award of £750,000.

Carter was one of a group of smokers to sue tobacco companies who were found guilty of knowingly selling products that caused illness to users.

Tony Silverman, chief European insurance analyst at Credit Lyonnais Securities, said that the UK insurance industry was only likely to be hit by claims if the US tobacco companies claimed on their product liability insurance.

However, he added that both sides were deadlocked, as insurers could use their health insurance arms to counter-claim against cigarette firms for selling a product that is injurious to people's health.

“The stand-off between insurers and tobacco companies is likely to go on for years,” he said.


The 2025 Insurance Times Awards took place on the evening of Wednesday 3rd December in the iconic Great Room of London’s Grosvenor House.

Hosted by comedian and actor Tom Allen, 34 Gold, 23 Silver and 22 Bronze awards were handed out across an amazing 34 categories recognising brilliance and innovation right across the breadth of UK general insurance.
Many congratulations to all the worthy winners and as always, huge thanks to our sponsors for their support and our judges for their expertise.

Topics