Appeal will settle who pays for failure of liability chain

Brokers caught up in a liability sub-broking chain are facing a bill of millions.

Hugh McGratten, a solicitor with Belfast firm McCloskey, said a case that could define the outcome for a further 559 claims will go to appeal on 14 September.

McGratten is representing Hi-Tec Roofing, a company that used Willis & Co Ltd [not Willis Group] to place liability cover. However, a judge ruled earlier in the year that cover was not incepted as the risk became lost in a sub-broking chain involving Laing & Co and Preston Whiteside.

It is understood that the original premium for the liability cover placed was approximately £5,000. It is understood a new premium of £12,000 was later spent securing adequate cover.

Although there was no written judgment, McGratten confirmed that in the case earlier this year, the judge ruled that a portion of the new premium must be paid by Willis & Co Ltd. The case has now been appealed, said McGratten. "And the outcome of another 559 cases depends on its outcome," he added.

It is understood that Willis & Co paid premiums to Laing & Co on behalf of around 25 Northern Ireland clients.

The 2025 Insurance Times Awards took place on the evening of Wednesday 3rd December in the iconic Great Room of London’s Grosvenor House.

Hosted by comedian and actor Tom Allen, 34 Gold, 23 Silver and 22 Bronze awards were handed out across an amazing 34 categories recognising brilliance and innovation right across the breadth of UK general insurance.
Many congratulations to all the worthy winners and as always, huge thanks to our sponsors for their support and our judges for their expertise.