Clegg Gifford chief executive Toby Clegg draws lessons from Disney’s strategic simplicity to argue that clear priorities, consistent execution and an empowered workforce can help insurance businesses thrive

I’ve long been fascinated by Disney’s boardroom battles from the 1980s onwards, as well as the extraordinary commercial success the studio enjoyed under Michael Eisner and later Bob Iger – two powerhouse characters who exemplify hard-charging, ambitious American corporate culture.

When pursuing the chief executive’s job, Iger decided to reduce his ambitions to a few strategic priorities. Whereas his rivals hired teams of management consultants and produced slick, lengthy presentations, largely setting out conventional approaches and granular financial forecasts, Iger took a different route.

His strategy was so simple that it initially horrified the board and nearly cost him the job. Yet that simplicity was its genius.

Simply put, his strategy centred on three things – one, find and buy the best content and intellectual property (IP). Two, maximise that content through further films and television series and three, monetise its appeal across the wider business.

His acquisitions of Marvel and Lucasfilm gave Disney vast intellectual property estates to mine. New productions kept them in front of audiences and provided content for the studio’s streaming platform Disney+, while theme parks and merchandise gave those audiences somewhere else to spend their money.

That said, Disney’s Star Wars sequels remain, to my mind, something of a crime against the series – although some television outings were half decent – and the Star Wars hotel also failed.

Clearly, strategic simplicity offers no immunity from getting individual tactical decisions wrong.

Nevertheless, Iger’s underlying logic was wonderfully easy to grasp. It makes me wonder why we so often insist on making strategy in insurance so complicated.

Lessons learnt

In this Iger-inspired spirit, my priorities would be straightforward – and I’m giving away no trade secrets, since they should be universally obvious.

Firstly, find defensible income streams among existing and prospective loyal clients with good reasons to stay. Choose a seam of business you understand, where expertise is rewarded and offer something worth renewing despite insurance being a grudge purchase.

There’s considerably more satisfaction, after all, in building a relationship that survives market cycles than in repeatedly buying someone’s fleeting affection with the cheapest quote.

Secondly, pursue insurance excellence. That means securing support from the best insurers for the risk in question, understanding the technicalities and getting the cover right.

Fit-for-purpose should be the starting point. We should be enthusiastic about the policies we arrange because we know what makes them good and, consequently, can explain their value.

Thirdly, invest in people and culture. Find talent, certainly, but recognise how much of it may already be sitting in your office awaiting encouragement.

Give people the technical education and confidence to exercise judgement. Back them and give them agency. They should feel there is a future for them within the business. Good people who feel trusted can achieve an enormous amount for it.

These are broad principles, of course, and arguably bloody obvious ones. But perhaps they are so obvious that we occasionally need reminding of them.

I am a bit of a hypocrite in this regard. I should confess that I haven’t always practised this restraint.

During one of our busiest periods, I used to produce an annual set of ’ten commandments’. These were the 10 strategic milestones we intended to achieve that year.

So, having commended Iger’s economy, I went further than him and borrowed directly from Moses.

But the important thing is that we achieved them. Each milestone was understandable, with real ownership attached. People knew what they were responsible for and why it mattered.

The result was a hugely enjoyable period in which progress was visible and productivity improved alongside the culture. There was real satisfaction in getting things done together.

Keeping focus

Three broad strategic priorities may therefore be enough, supported by several practical milestones that turn them into action.

The danger comes when every departmental ambition becomes a supposed strategic priority and nobody can remember which should prevail when resources become stretched.

One chief executive put it brilliantly to me recently – the best delivery comes when teams are allowed to focus on completing projects rather than constantly being hauled from one priority to another. That focus is vital not only for delivery, but for keeping people sane and productive.

Hear, hear.

Communication also belongs at the heart of this exercise. Every member of staff should understand where the business is going and how their work contributes.

Repeating the message like an electioneering politician may be tiresome, but it is part of leadership. Equally important is listening when the people expected to deliver the strategy explain where things are going awry.

That understanding feeds directly into culture. People take greater ownership when the purpose is clear, management behaves consistently, everyone understands the common goal and leaders remain realistic about progress.

Peter Drucker’s famous line about culture eating strategy for breakfast has always struck me as only half-right.

The two are symbiotic. Strategy gives people direction, while culture helps determine whether they want to stay for the journey and deliver against those priorities.

Clear choices, properly communicated, help build the culture that makes those choices work.

If the people doing the work understand the strategy and enjoy putting it into practice, you have a decent chance of succeeding.

Failing that, you can always retreat to the sofa and watch a comforting Disney film.