‘Many of the issues that have been highlighted in this latest report were barely touched on a year ago, which shows the FCA did not do a thorough job,’ says managing director

The FCA has been urged to tackle the “root cause” of problems with insurance claims after its first joint thematic report with the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) highlighted widespread delays and poor communication.

Almost 66,000 complaints concerning delays, administration and customer service reached the FOS during the five years to 31 March 2026, representing around 31% of approximately 214,800 insurance complaints recorded over the period.

Half of complaints primarily concerning claims were upheld, compared with an average uphold rate of 34% across all insurance complaints.

James Daley, managing director of independent consumer group Fairer Finance, said the findings validated concerns previously raised about claims handling.

He said: “The FCA and Ombudsman’s first thematic report lays bare the very real problems in the insurance claims space.

“While many in the industry dismissed the Which? super complaint, this latest data validates many of the concerns they raised last year.”

‘Root cause’

Daley argued that the figures also raised questions over the regulator’s previous examination of claims handling.

“It’s barely 15 months since the FCA completed its review of home and travel insurance claims,” he said.

“Many of the issues that have been highlighted in this latest report were barely touched on a year ago, which shows the FCA did not do a thorough job.”

Daley added that the new evidence meant it was “vital that the FCA gets stuck into fixing the root cause” of the problem.

In particular, he highlighted the role of third parties, claiming that a “lack of independence of loss adjusters is a key part of the problem”.

Rocio Concha, Which? director of policy and advocacy, said the report reinforced concerns raised in the consumer group’s super-complaint last year.

The complaint raised concerns in home and travel insurance markets, with it containing evidence and original research based on surveys of thousands of insurance customers, in-depth interviews with people who have experienced problems, analysis of thousands of FOS decisions and independent legal analysis.

Concha said delays, poor communication and inadequate customer service had been “deeply-ingrained for years”, leaving customers chasing insurers for updates while claims remained unresolved.

Concha welcomed collaboration between the FCA and FOS, particularly around oversight of third-party claims handlers, but called for stronger intervention.

She added: “What’s needed now is firm action from the FCA to break its perpetual cycle of reviews and finally tackle longstanding problems in the insurance market.”