Telematics has promised fairer pricing and safer roads for more than a decade, yet adoption remains concentrated among younger drivers. But is technology still holding it back, or does the industry need to rethink what customers actually want?

The theory behind telematics has always been persuasive.

Motor insurers traditionally calculate risk using factors such as age, occupation, postcode, vehicle and claims history, none of which tell an insurer precisely how those individuals drive.

Telematics promised to change that. Actual driving behaviour could help insurers price risk more accurately, reward safer motorists and intervene earlier when things go wrong.

Yet it remains far from universal.

Its strongest foothold is still among younger and higher-risk motorists, for whom the difference between conventional and telematics premiums can make sharing driving data financially worthwhile.

That leaves the industry with a more fundamental question. If telematics works, why have so many motorists remained unconvinced?

Adoption is not acceptance

For Andrew Brown-Allan, chief growth officer at IMS, economics has historically been a central constraint.

He recalled that professionally installed black-box technology and first-year data services could cost around £120. Newer approaches have progressively reduced that cost, with IMS now targeting roughly £1 at scale for collecting a driving score through its on-device technology.

Manjit Rana, executive vice-president for insurance at Clearspeed, however, questions whether making telematics cheaper tackles the more fundamental challenge.

“Telematics has demonstrated its usefulness without consistently earning customer preference. Those are different achievements,” he said.

For young drivers, the high price of conventional insurance means accepting monitoring can be an economic necessity, rather than evidence they actively want the product.

“The harder test comes when conventional cover becomes affordable. Have we created something the driver wants to keep?” Rana asked.

He added: “If customers see leaving telematics as graduating from it, that tells us something important about the proposition.”

Data from Consumer Intelligence illustrates telematics’ strength among younger customers. Catherine Carey, head of marketing at Customer Intelligence said almost half of young drivers have been offered a telematics quote, 27% currently have a policy and 34% have used telematics insurance before.

Telematics brands also return the lowest prices for under-25s around 75% of the time across the four main price comparison websites.

But the equation changes as drivers age and premiums fall. A substantial saving can justify considerable inconvenience – a marginal one may not.

The value of privacy

Privacy has long offered another explanation for telematics’ limited penetration.

Brown-Allan said motorists can support the principle of being priced according to how they actually drive while remaining uncomfortable with sending an insurer granular information from every journey.

IMS’s Global UBI Consumer Study of 1,044 participants aged 25 to 54 across five countries in April 2025 found that 62% of UK responders were concerned about granular trip-level data leaving their smartphone. Just 32% said they were comfortable with insurers collecting telematics data, while 49% preferred smartphone-based collection.

IMS Edge Intelligence, for example, can process detailed journey information on the customer’s smartphone, allowing a driver to generate a score before choosing whether to share it with an insurer.

But Rana argues that privacy should not be treated as a fixed consumer objection. People willingly surrender personal information elsewhere when they believe the outcome is sufficiently valuable, citing dating apps as an example.

With insurance, the problem is that the benefit can appear uncertain while the potential consequences of a poor driving score feel much more tangible.

That raises the possibility that what appears to be a privacy problem is really a value problem.

Matthew Connell, director of policy and public affairs at the Chartered Insurance Institute (CII), said insurers’ approaches to telematics have also differed significantly.

“Some have focused on rewarding drivers for good driving and offered telematics as a benefit. Others have used telematics to monitor drivers and penalise them,” he said.

Connell said motorists can perceive driving without telematics as offering greater freedom, citing concerns that actions such as sudden braking to avoid a pothole or compensating for another road user’s behaviour could count against them.

Keeping data securely on a device may alleviate one concern. It does not necessarily persuade a customer that being scored is something they want.

What does the driver get?

That question becomes particularly important as insurers look beyond higher-risk customers.

Ross Brown, associate director commercial at Markerstudy Retail, said: “For more established motorists, premium reductions alone are often less compelling.”

For these drivers, he believes the proposition needs to extend to crash assistance, driving insights, rewards, personalised renewal benefits and enhanced support throughout the customer journey.

Rana makes a similar distinction.

“We need to distinguish better risk selection from a better customer proposition,” he said.

Identifying a careful driver may help an insurer acquire profitable business, but does not itself create value for the customer. Preventing a collision, providing help sooner or reducing disruption following an accident does.

“A score can support that proposition, but few people wake up wanting a more accurate insurance score,” Rana said.

It goes to the fundamental question at the heart of telematics. Detailed behavioural data may be enormously valuable to an underwriter, but why should the motorist value its collection equally?

Carey said the issue ultimately comes down to the exchange between insurer and customer: “The question is whether insurers have established a value exchange that feels worthwhile and fair.

“If the proposition feels weighted entirely in the insurer’s favour, it is unlikely to encourage wider adoption.”

Rana argued that an accident alert creates little value if it feeds into a process that still waits for the customer to telephone, while a driving signal simply adds complexity if nobody can explain or resolve a disputed result.

“The objective should be better decisions and faster intervention. Data volume is a poor measure of progress,” he said.

Oxbow Partners raises a similar commercial dilemma. Behavioural data can provide predictive insight, but insurers must weigh the incremental benefit against integration costs, customer friction and the considerable amount of information they already have available through conventional rating factors.

The challenge may therefore no longer be proving that telematics can tell insurers something useful. It is showing customers that those insights can meaningfully improve their experience of insurance.

A future without telematics?

Perhaps the biggest assumption worth challenging is that mass adoption means persuading millions more motorists to buy something resembling today’s telematics policy.

Brown-Allan sees potential for driving scores to increasingly become an input at the point of quote rather than requiring customers to spend an entire policy year participating in conventional usage-based insurance.

Applying his own rule of thumb to IMS’s consumer research, he suggested adoption could potentially reach the “early 20%” range, which would represent a significant step change for the UK market.

“Because we’ve spent 15 years getting to barely even double digit penetration of the total motor market. If we get that to 20% and you could start to make the same sorts of projections around what that impact that might have an accident frequency, public cost, cost to insurers, lost life, then that obviously is a fantastic end goal,” he said.

Rana envisages something more innovative – a “guardian angel” service that drivers could retain when they change insurer, providing safety support, relevant hazard warnings and assistance following a collision. Insurance pricing could become only one benefit within that relationship.

Brown nevertheless believes telematics will become “increasingly mainstream over time”, with today’s telematics customers eventually becoming mainstream motorists while connected vehicles and manufacturer data make collecting information more seamless.

Oxbow Partners sees another possibility altogether.

The consultantcy firm said: “The future of telematics may not be more telematics policies. It may be telematics disappearing into the pricing and insurance ecosystem.”

Perhaps that is ultimately how the technology fulfils some of the expectations placed upon it.

Success does not necessarily require every motorist to buy a product labelled telematics, permanently monitor their driving and regularly consult a score.

Behavioural and vehicle data could instead quietly become part of pricing, safety and claims, surfacing when it can provide something useful and retreating when it cannot.

After years spent asking why telematics has failed to go mainstream, the industry’s question may therefore need to change.

The technology has already demonstrated what it can measure. The harder task is deciding what motorists actually want it to do.