Concern over with-profits life arms threaten smaller mutuals

The Financial Services Authority (FSA) is demanding mutual insurers prove they have a viable future amid concerns over declining sales, The Times reports.

A recent letter sent by Jon Pain, the FSA’s managing director of supervision to the chief executives of Britain’s 57 mutual insurers and friendly societies suggested that some societies should consider winding themselves up.

Aimed at those with “with-profits” life arms, the letter said: “If a mutual is unable to continue to effect new business on terms which also enable the existing with-profits business to run off fairly, it may be required to close to all new business.”

Biggest are safe

The biggest mutual societies, such as Royal London and LV, are not expected to have any difficulty complying, the Times said.

The Association of Financial Mutuals said: “We are disappointed with the approach the FSA is taking but we’re keen to work with them towards a reasonable outcome.

“The whole issue of making sure firms have a viable future is not a new one — it’s something we’ve all been working on for a number of years.”

The 2025 Insurance Times Awards took place on the evening of Wednesday 3rd December in the iconic Great Room of London’s Grosvenor House.

Hosted by comedian and actor Tom Allen, 34 Gold, 23 Silver and 22 Bronze awards were handed out across an amazing 34 categories recognising brilliance and innovation right across the breadth of UK general insurance.
Many congratulations to all the worthy winners and as always, huge thanks to our sponsors for their support and our judges for their expertise.

Topics